Publication of Audit Findings into SPH Media Trust's Inflated Circulation Numbers
Ministry of Home AffairsSpeakers
Summary
This question concerns MP Ms Hazel Poa’s inquiries regarding the public release of investigation findings into SPH Media Trust's (SMT) inflated circulation numbers and why the organization did not voluntarily disclose the discrepancy. Minister Josephine Teo clarified that the discrepancy did not result in a loss of public funds, so Government funding for SMT’s technology and talent development remains unchanged. She explained that SMT’s Audit and Risk Committee is conducting further investigations and must refer any evidence of fraud or wrongdoing to the relevant agencies for follow-up. Although communication strategies are internal matters for SMT’s board, Minister Josephine Teo stated that the Ministry expects the organization to be transparent and uphold public trust. Ultimately, SMT must rectify its processes and share its findings once investigations are complete to ensure accountability regarding its circulation data.
Transcript
28 Ms Hazel Poa asked the Minister for Communications and Information whether an external investigation on the fraud involving SPH Media Trust's circulation figures will be conducted and the report made public.
29 Ms Hazel Poa asked the Minister for Communications and Information whether the Ministry will share with the public SPH Media Trust's review of the overstated circulation data, including accounts provided by the executives involved in the case.
30 Ms Hazel Poa asked the Minister for Communications and Information whether the Ministry has been informed of the reasons for SPH Media Trust not breaking the news on the overstated circulation numbers of their own accord but through media queries.
Mrs Josephine Teo: These questions have been addressed in my reply to Question Nos 2 to 18 for oral answer on the Order Paper for 6 February 2023 and to subsequent clarifications sought by Members. [Please refer to "Government's Response to SPH Media Trust's Inflated Circulation Numbers", Official Report, 6 February 2023, Vol 95, Issue 81, Oral Answers to Questions section.]
In essence, the findings of circulation discrepancy for the period of SPH Media Trust (SMT)'s internal review from September 2020 to March 2022 have not resulted in the loss of public funds. There is no change to the Government’s decision to provide funding to support SMT’s capability development. There is also no change to the amount of funding as it is targeted towards technology development, talent development and the strengthening of newsrooms, particularly vernacular newsrooms.
I had also explained that certain questions would be better addressed by SMT after its Audit and Risk Committee has completed its further investigations and shared its findings. If there is evidence of fraud or other wrongdoing, SMT is obliged to do the right and lawful thing to refer to a relevant agency for follow-up.
SMT’s approach to communications both within and outside the organisation, is a matter for its board and management to consider. Even so, MCI has made clear its expectations that SMT has a responsibility to uphold public trust. It must rectify what needs to be rectified, and be transparent with the public on how it intends to proceed.