Need for Another Study by NHB to Assess Historical, Heritage and Architectural Significance of 38 Oxley Road for Preservation
Ministry of Culture, Community and YouthSpeakers
Summary
This question concerns Mr Leong Mun Wai’s inquiry regarding the necessity of a new National Heritage Board (NHB) study for 38 Oxley Road following the 2018 Ministerial Committee report. Minister for Culture, Community and Youth Edwin Tong Chun Fai explained that while prior research existed, it was never formally presented to the Preservation of Sites and Monuments Advisory Board (PSM AB) for independent assessment. In light of a recent demolition application, the NHB has now initiated this standard process to evaluate the site’s eligibility for preservation as a National Monument. The PSM AB will conduct an objective review of the research to provide a recommendation to the NHB for further action. Finally, the Minister for Culture, Community and Youth will determine whether to issue a Preservation Order under the Preservation of Monuments Act to ensure all options are fully considered.
Transcript
43 Mr Leong Mun Wai asked the Minister for Culture, Community and Youth why is another study by the National Heritage Board (NHB) needed to assess whether 38 Oxley Road has national historical, heritage and architectural significance as to be worthy of preservation, in view that the Ministerial Committee on 38 Oxley Road had assessed in 2018 that it has “architectural, heritage and historical significance” based on a research report by NHB.
Mr Edwin Tong Chun Fai: The National Heritage Board (NHB) conducts research on buildings, sites or structures with the potential to be considered as a National Monument. Such research could cover technical aspects, such as the historic, cultural, architectural and national importance of the building, site or structure. The research is then presented to the Preservation of Sites and Monuments Advisory Board (PSM AB), set up by NHB under section 7 of the Preservation of Monuments Act, for their independent assessment, as part of the decision-making process on whether the building, site or structure should be preserved as a National Monument. The PSM AB makes this assessment based on objective criteria, for all sites which have the potential to be preserved as a National Monument.
In the case of 38 Oxley Road, this research was done by NHB for the 2018 Ministerial Committee Report. While the research was incorporated into the Report, the Ministerial Committee concluded that no decision had to be made at that point in time, and all options would be kept open. Hence, the research was not presented to the PSM AB for their assessment then on the suitability of 38 Oxley Road as a National Monument.
In view of the recent application by the owner to demolish the building, which would immediately rule out a proper and full consideration of options, NHB has commenced the process to determine 38 Oxley Road’s eligibility and suitability for preservation as a National Monument. This includes presenting the research to the PSM AB for their independent assessment. Based on the assessment, NHB would then provide a recommendation to the Minister for Culture, Community and Youth to decide whether to issue a Preservation Order for the Site under the Preservation of Monuments Act.
This follows the usual assessment process before any building, site or structure can be preserved as a National Monument, and we will apply this accordingly to 38 Oxley Road.