Cost of Restoration and Additional Works Done on Black and White Bungalows since 2018
Ministry of LawSpeakers
Summary
This question concerns Ms Hazel Poa’s inquiry regarding the frequency of black and white bungalows being rented at guide rent, restoration costs exceeding $500,000, swimming pool approvals, and adjacent land clearing since 2018. Second Minister for Law Edwin Tong Chun Fai responded that the Singapore Land Authority does not specifically track these categories but confirmed that properties are rented at or above guide rent. He explained that site clearance requests are assessed on their individual merits, considering factors like public health, safety, and the landlord’s interests. The Minister referred to previous ministerial statements for management details and noted that maintenance solutions are determined by site-specific circumstances. This approach ensures all decisions regarding heritage bungalows are made to safeguard the state’s interests while following established rental and maintenance frameworks.
Transcript
6 Ms Hazel Poa asked the Minister for Law since 2018 and for black and white bungalows, what is the number of instances of the Singapore Land Authority (i) renting them out at exactly the amount of guide rent, (ii) spending over $500,000 in essential repair works to restore them, (iii) allowing the tenants to build swimming pools within the rented properties and (iv) clearing adjacent state land on the tenant’s request which is not part of the rented property.
Mr Edwin Tong Chun Fai (Second Minister for Law): The Singapore Land Authority (SLA) does not specifically track the number of cases involving residential heritage bungalows managed by SLA, which fall into the categories set out by the Member.
SLA’s approach with regard to the management of state properties was explained in detail in Parliament on 3 July 2023. [Please refer to (a) "Rentals of State Properties", Official Report, 3 July 2023, Vol 95, Issue 105, Ministerial Statements section; and (b) "Approvals for Rental of and Works to be Done at State-owned Bungalows", Official Report, 3 July 2023, Vol 95, Issue 105, Written Answers to Questions section.] The Member can refer to the speeches as well as to the various clarifications addressed in Parliament. We highlight the following two points.
On the rental of properties at exactly the guide rent: as explained in Parliament on 3 July 2023, SLA’s practice for its residential state properties is that these properties can be rented out if the offered rent is equal to or above the guide rent. Thus, there would have been cases where residential heritage bungalows were rented out exactly at the guide rent.
On site clearance – SLA’s approach to cases where there is feedback on issues related to vegetated land located within and adjacent to the properties, including whether site clearance is required, is to assess each case on its merits, depending on the specific circumstances and always with a view to safeguarding SLA’s interests as the landlord. SLA will take into consideration, amongst other factors, whether there are any public health and safety concerns, the specific tenancy details and how SLA’s interests would be best achieved in the context of the tenancy and its surrounding circumstances. The solution to the issues may also be site-specific.