Budget Meal Criteria in New Lease Renewal Requirements for HDB Rental Coffee Shops
Ministry of National DevelopmentSpeakers
Summary
This question concerns the pricing criteria for budget meals and the rationale for requiring fewer budget meals during HDB coffee shop lease renewals. Assoc Prof Jamus Jerome Lim inquired about the dollar amount defining these meals and why the requirement was set at four instead of six. Minister for National Development Desmond Lee responded that prices are proposed by operators and reviewed by HDB, typically ranging from $3 to $3.50, to ensure local affordability. He explained that while Price-Quality Method tenderers provide six meals, other renewing operators are only required to provide four meals and two drinks to facilitate their transition. To further support this policy, HDB offers a 5% rent discount for one year to operators renewing their tenancies under these conditions.
Transcript
24 Assoc Prof Jamus Jerome Lim asked the Minister for National Development (a) what is the dollar amount that is deemed as a budget meal under the new lease renewal requirements for HDB rental coffee shops; and (b) in view of the new requirement to provide four budget meals spread across different stalls, what is the motivation behind the decision to reduce the number of meals from six to four.
Mr Desmond Lee: The price of the budget meal is proposed by the operator and reviewed by the Housing and Development Board (HDB) to ensure they are reasonable and remain affordable in reference to nearby options. This strikes a balance between the operator’s business sustainability and the needs of residents for affordable food options. Rental coffee shops leased under the Price-Quality Method tenders typically provide budget food options with prices at around $3 to $3.50 across the estates.
Existing coffee shop operators who successfully tendered to rent their coffee shops under the Price-Quality Method will continue to provide six budget meals and one budget drink, as stipulated in the conditions of their original tender bids. However, operators of coffee shops who did not tender to rent their coffee shops under the Price-Quality Method will require time to make the transition with their stallholders. Hence, we will only require them to provide four budget meals and two drinks as a condition for the renewal of the coffee shop tenancy, until further review.
To further ease the transition for operators and stallholders to offer the budget meals, HDB is offering them a 5% discount on the renewal rents for a period of one year.